I’ve been a USAA customer for years — checking, auto, insurance, the works.
And like most of their members, I joined because USAA wasn’t just a bank. It was our bank thanks to my father’s service in the United States Air Force. This is built for people who serve, for their families, and for folks who get the late-night deployment calls and the PCS orders that turn life upside down.
So when Task & Purpose reported that USAA was freezing loans for troops during a possible government shutdown — yeah, that one stung.
Let’s start with the basics: this wasn’t technically “wrong.” Banks make business decisions all the time to manage risk. A shutdown means paychecks could stop. That’s fair game for finance departments.
But here’s the kicker — USAA isn’t supposed to be like other banks. Their entire brand is built on trust, loyalty, and the idea that “we’ve got your six.” When the chips were down, they blinked.
And that’s the part marketing departments never seem to grasp — you don’t build emotional equity through commercials. You build it in the moment when people are scared, uncertain, or about to make a hard call.
Imagine if, instead of freezing credit lines, USAA had gone the other direction:
A statement saying, “We understand the uncertainty. We’ll stand by our members, no matter what Washington does.”
That’s not just good optics — that’s a brand-defining moment. The kind people are remembered for decades.
Instead, they chose silence and policy memos.
Which is like watching a teammate drop the ball on the one-yard line, then shrug it off.
Here’s what I would’ve done — and USAA’s CMO, if you’re listening, feel free to steal this:
Send an email to every member reaffirming support during potential pay disruptions.
Launch a short-term relief program — even if only symbolic — to demonstrate good faith.
And communicate like humans. No boilerplate. No “as part of our ongoing commitment” fluff. Say, “We know you’re worried. We’ve got your back.”
It’s that simple. And it would’ve cost them less than one week of national TV ad spend.
What this shows is that brand authenticity isn’t built in campaigns — it’s built in crises.
When your audience is made up of people who’ve literally signed up to defend the country, “brand loyalty” isn’t a marketing metric. It’s a moral contract.
As a USAA customer, I’m not angry — I’m disappointed.
Because this was a moment where they could’ve turned fear into faith.
And instead, they froze both.
Your move, USAA.